How Texas Prosecutors Build a Criminal Case

An experienced criminal defense lawyer can counter their tactics

Texas prosecutors have the full weight of law enforcement behind them, giving them a significant advantage in building a case against defendants. From the moment of an arrest in Austin or the surrounding area, police officers, investigators, and forensic teams work to collect evidence that supports the state’s version of events.

Prosecutors then shape that evidence into a case designed to convince a jury of guilt. They have access to extensive resources, from lab testing to expert witnesses, and they use legal strategies designed to secure convictions – not necessarily to uncover the truth.

Being charged with a serious crime in Texas can put your future, freedom, and reputation at risk. The penalties for these offenses can include lengthy prison sentences, steep fines, and permanent criminal records. Prosecutors aggressively pursue convictions in cases involving:

DWI
Drug possession
Aggravated assault
Domestic violence
Sexual assault
Weapons charges
White-collar crimes
Homicide

But no case is perfect. The prosecution’s version of events is often built on selective evidence, flawed witness testimony, and aggressive legal tactics. A strong, Texas criminal defense lawyer can expose these weaknesses, challenge assumptions, and protect the accused from unfair prosecution.

How Texas prosecutors build a criminal case

The Travis County District Attorney’s Office and other prosecutors in Central Texas take an aggressive approach to criminal cases. From minor offenses to serious felonies, they work closely with law enforcement to gather evidence, file charges, and prepare for trial.

Criminal cases in Austin typically begin with an investigation by the Austin Police Department, the Travis County Sheriff’s Office, or another law enforcement agency. Officers gather evidence in several ways:

Physical and forensic evidence: DNA, fingerprints, and drug tests are often used to build cases, but forensic methods are not always foolproof. Errors in handling evidence can compromise results.
Witness statements: Police interview witnesses at the scene or during follow-up investigations. However, witness accounts are often inconsistent or influenced by law enforcement pressure.
Surveillance and digital evidence: With Austin’s growing use of public and private surveillance cameras, prosecutors often rely on video footage. They may also use cellphone records, GPS data, and social media activity.
Searches and seizures: Law enforcement may obtain warrants to search homes, vehicles, or electronic devices. However, mistakes in obtaining or executing a warrant can make this evidence inadmissible in court.
Interrogations and confessions: Police use interrogation tactics that can lead to false or coerced confessions. Defendants who speak without an attorney present may unknowingly provide the prosecution with damaging statements.

How the state decides to prosecute a case

After law enforcement completes an investigation, the case is referred to the prosecution. In Travis County, the District Attorney’s Office reviews police reports, evidence, and witness statements to determine whether charges should be filed.

For misdemeanor cases, such as DWI or drug possession, prosecutors often proceed based on the arresting officer’s report. In felony cases, such as aggravated assault or drug trafficking, a grand jury may be involved. Grand juries meet in secret, and only the prosecution presents evidence – giving the state significant control over the charging process.

It’s also common for prosecutors to overcharge defendants by stacking multiple charges or escalating the severity of an offense. This tactic pressures defendants into accepting plea deals rather than risking harsher penalties at trial.

Notably, prosecutors do not need absolute proof to file charges. If they believe they can convince a jury of guilt, they will proceed. This means that weak or circumstantial evidence can still result in serious criminal charges.

Prosecutorial strategies: How the state builds a conviction case

Once charges are filed, the prosecution focuses on securing a conviction. Their approach often includes:

Plea bargains: Prosecutors frequently push defendants to accept plea deals, even in weak cases. Defendants who accept plea agreements often avoid trial but may face significant fines, probation, or jail time.
Selective presentation of evidence: The state highlights evidence that supports its case while downplaying or ignoring details that could create doubt.
Use of expert witnesses: Prosecutors may call on forensic experts, accident reconstruction specialists, or medical professionals to bolster their case. However, defense attorneys can challenge their credibility and methods.

Austin-area prosecutors have the advantage of extensive legal resources, but their cases are not always airtight. A skilled defense attorney can expose weaknesses in their arguments and shift the outcome in favor of the accused.

How a strong defense can dismantle the state’s case

Just because a person is charged with a crime does not mean a conviction is inevitable. Defense attorneys use proven strategies to challenge the state’s case, protect constitutional rights, and secure the best possible outcome.

Challenging evidence and police procedure

One of the most effective ways to weaken the prosecution’s case is to scrutinize how evidence was obtained. This includes:

Illegal searches and seizures: If law enforcement violated Fourth Amendment rights by conducting an unlawful search, the evidence can be thrown out.
Flawed forensic evidence: Lab tests, fingerprint analysis, and drug testing are not infallible. A defense attorney can challenge the accuracy of forensic reports.
Witness credibility issues: Witnesses may have conflicting statements, personal biases, or unreliable memories. Exposing these inconsistencies can create reasonable doubt.

Fighting unfair charging decisions

Prosecutors sometimes overcharge defendants to increase the chances of a plea deal. A skilled defense lawyer can challenge excessive charges and push for case reductions. In Austin, alternatives such as pretrial diversion programs may be available for first-time offenders, helping them avoid a permanent criminal record.

In felony cases, a defense attorney can challenge a grand jury indictment by filing pretrial motions to dismiss weak charges or suppress questionable evidence.

Exposing the flaws in the prosecution’s strategy

No criminal case is perfect. A strong defense can highlight inconsistencies, undermine expert testimony, and show that the state’s case is not as strong as it appears. Some key defense tactics include:

Cross-examining witnesses: Questioning witnesses can reveal biases, memory lapses, or contradictions in their statements.
Challenging expert testimony: Prosecutors often rely on forensic experts, but their conclusions are not always scientific or reliable. Defense attorneys can present counter-experts to challenge their findings.
Presenting alternative theories: A defense team can introduce evidence that contradicts the prosecution’s narrative, creating reasonable doubt.
Highlighting gaps in the evidence: No case is perfect. A defense attorney can expose missing evidence, unreliable sources, or conflicting statements that weaken the state’s argument.

When handled strategically, these defense approaches can lead to reduced charges, case dismissals, or not-guilty verdicts.

Why hiring a defense lawyer is essential

A criminal charge in Austin is not something to fight alone. Prosecutors have extensive resources, but a knowledgeable defense attorney understands how to counter their tactics. Without legal representation, defendants risk being pressured into plea deals, facing maximum sentences, or losing their rights due to legal missteps.

A lawyer protects more than just a legal case – they safeguard a person’s future, freedom, and reputation. The criminal justice system is designed to be difficult to navigate, but with the right legal advocate on your side, the path forward becomes clearer.

Texas prosecutors are relentless in their pursuit of convictions, but that doesn’t mean every case is unwinnable. Law enforcement’s evidence, charging decisions, and trial strategies all have vulnerabilities that a skilled defense attorney can expose.

Protect your future with Botsford & Roark

When the stakes are high, you need a defense team that knows how to win. The Austin criminal defense attorneys at Botsford & Roark are committed to protecting your reputation, your future, and your freedom. With decades of experience handling complex criminal cases – including DWI, sexual assault, domestic violence, and Title IX accusations – our firm knows how to challenge the prosecution’s case and fight for the best possible outcome. Botsford & Roark has secured dismissals, exonerations, and favorable outcomes for high-profile individuals, student-athletes, and Central Texans facing serious criminal charges, including successfully defending Governor Rick Perry and challenging flawed Title IX proceedings at the University of Texas.

Charged with a crime? Contact Botsford & Roark today for a confidential, free consultation to discuss your case and start building a strong defense.

“Best it gets, hands down. It was an easy and stressless experience having Brian handle my case, and I am forever grateful I was pointed in his direction. Do not think twice about having him represent you. From day one it was well laid out for me what the plan was, and he made it happen. Highly recommend!” - Blake B., ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Click here for a printable PDF of this article, “How Texas Prosecutors Build a Criminal Case.”